Special Guest Stars Gary Cole as Kurt McVeigh Guest Stars Brenda Braxton as Madeline Gilford Stephen Lang as David Cord Joshua Echebiri as Devin Jordan Boatman as Associate Lucy Jane Lynch as Madeline Starkey Geoffrey Owens as Daniel Aaron Tveit as Spencer Zschau Bebe Neuwirth as Judge Claudia Friend David Alford as Benjamin Dafoe Eric T. Miller as V.A. Spokesman Michael Countryman as Mr. Hookstratten Elisha Lawson as Gunnar Neustadt Larry Bull as VA Employee Daniel Pearce as Reif Van De Berg Marc Kudisch as Mr. Rottenberg Co Starring Samaria Nixon-Fleming as Paralegal Louisa Mallory Portnoy as Anne Michael Di Liberto as Author One Ray Demattis as Irwin Mandel Tracy McMullan as Author Two Uncredited Jonathan Coulton voices Jonathan Coulton