Guest Stars Elvis Nolasco as Nat Pettigrew Dominic Fumusa as Father Louis Gigante Korey Jackson as Livingston Wingate Paul Sorvino as Frank Costello Chazz Palminteri as Giuseppe "Joe" Bonanno Grace Porter as Betty Shabazz Maurice Jones as Captain Omar Isaach De Bankolé as Monsieur 98 Justin Bartha as Robert Morgenthau Leopold Manswell as Captain Henry Method Man as Sam Christian Annabella Sciorra as Fay Bonnano A$AP Ferg as Reggie Co Starring Markuann Smith as Junie Byrd Afi Bijou as Sister Marny Bo Dietl as Thomas Lucchese Anthony Aquilino as Carlo Gambino Rony Clanton as Cecil Stephen Christopher Marshall as Federal Marshal Lamar Kareem Cheston as Lamar Rockwell Dee Morris as Henchman #2 David Chen as Henchman #1