Guest Stars Happy Anderson as Jimmy Annabelle Attanasio as Dorothy Walcott Arielle Goldman as Genevieve Everidge Stephen Spinella as Pastor A.D. Elkins Anthony Rapp as Dr. Thurman Drexler Gibson Frazier as Harold Prettyman Phil Burke as Doctor Michael Cumpsty as Judge Parkinson Bothamly Gia Crovatin as Clara Horner Will Brill as Leo Guggenheim Kelly Aaron as Society Lady Jason Babinsky as Mt. Sinai Doctor John Paul Cayetano as Horse Wrangler Co Starring Andrew Rannells as Frazier H. Wingo Ben Livingston as Dr. Mays Alexandra Roxo as Cate Jerry Miller as Cromartie Orderly Yury Tsykun as Mr. Tibor David Sedgwick as Mr. Horner Kate MacCluggage as Mary Dillon Mathews as Doctor Gillian Williams as Henny Vin Hamilton as Operating Theater Reporter Steven Jaehnert as Construction Worker Jesse Jantzen as Referee David Kubicka as Griscom Christina Paterno as Nurse Katrina E. Perkins as Upper Class Pedestrian Christian Paul Sherwood as Patient Tom Stratford as Immigrant James Zeiss as Wrestling Spectator
