Guest Stars Kaitlyn Dever as Abbi Miller Julia Goldani Telles as Kailey Edward Asner as Mr. Holmes Lucas Hedges as Jesse Wheeler O'Shea Jackson, Jr. as Cooper George Wallace as Principal Wallace Brendan Scannell as Caleb Rose Grace Song as Susie Xu Co Starring Andy Cohen as Himself Devin Sidell as Assistant Principal Megan Truong as Kelly Kim Lily Liu as Susie's Mom Emily Flyr as Alyssa