Guest Stars Amanda Leighton as Teenage Sophie Rachel Hilson as Teenage Beth Adam Korson as Elijah Matt Corboy as Matt Dixon Mike C. Manning as Tyler Carl Lumbly as Abe Clarke Goran Višnjić as Vincent Kelly Jazlyn Martin as Stacey Robins Co Starring Lexi Johnson as Beth's Assistant Wendy Braun as Linda Darroe Marcel Antonio Mendoza as Ari Michael James Lazar as Joseph Tony Robinette as PA Spencer Moss as Student Taylor Coleman as Lily Isa Eden as Little Beth