Guest Stars Meredith Garretson as Kate Hawthorne Gary Farmer as Dan Twelvetrees Diana Bang as Nurse Ellen Jenna Lamia as Judy Cooper Gracelyn Awad Rinke as Sahar Alex Barima as David Logan Justin Rain as Elliot Nathan Fillion voices Octopus / No. 42 Co Starring Kaylayla Raine as Jay Alvin Sanders as Lewis Thompson Julian Nelson as Lanky Stoner Kevin Mundy as Patience 1st Base Coach Lossen Chambers as Doctor Bishop Sandy Minh Abley as Woman Sweeping Terry Streete as Male Nurse Dan Yang as Man Passing Coulton Jackson as Right Fielder Rosie Pidcock as Cindy Kate Whiddington as Six-Year-Old Girl Dave Santana as Mr. Souza Michael F. Roselli as Orderly