Guest Stars Meredith Garretson as Kate Hawthorne Jenna Lamia as Judy Cooper Gracelyn Awad Rinke as Sahar Alex Barima as David Logan Sarah Podemski as Kayla Alex Borstein as Carlyn Co Starring Alvin Sanders as Lewis Thompson Elle Rivas as Young D'Arcy Jessica Halliburton as Young Liv Zara Bacic as Young Asta Lukas Goas as Young Ben Matthew Kevin Anderson as Agent Fisher Peter Graham-Gaudreau as Male Teacher Acahkos Johnson as Young Kayla Mike Mitchell as Creepy Boss Bradley Duffy as Passed Out Drunk Lilly Dean as Young Judy