Guest Stars Andrea Martin as Sister Andrea Boris McGiver as Monsignor Matthew Korecki Tim Matheson as Edward Tragoren Leon Addison Brown as Minister Ato Essandoh as Nathan Elijah M. Cooper as Elijah Michael Laurence as Gregory Beale Celeste Arias as Whitney Festa Michael Izquierdo as Travis Festa Gregory Porter Miller as Charles Gibson Frazier as Asa Linden Zachary Golinger as Sebi Festa