Guest Stars Jackson Pace as Wyatt Harris Amy Acker as Catherine Harper Robyn Lively as Marlene Harris Tamala Jones as Sarina Washington Matthew Alan as Mr. Conrad Kate Cook as Mrs. Conrad Co Starring Natalie Korzon as Jenni Ludwig Manukian as Joseph Hank Northrop as Uni Cop Dominique Washington as Waitress Megan Easton as Danica Hendry Elsa George as Katie Conrad Emily Trujillo as Server