Guest Stars David Magidoff as Teddy Reed Gizel Jimenez as Tess Michael Cyril Creighton as Fred Jr. Gregory Cruz as Abraham Brown Fredric Lehne as Edward Olsen Co Starring Andrew Fama as Scott Oscar Wahlberg as Zach Kimmy Anne Dunn as Lily David J. Curtis as Gig Dustin Tucker as Pastor Brian Steven M. Robertson as Matt Caldwell