Guest Stars Jalen Thomas Brooks as Colton Davidson Dave Annable as Dan Miller Tamara Feldman as Denise Davidson Paula Marshall as Gale Davidson Bella Samman as Faye Garrett Kruithof as Boyd "Hot Rod" McNeil Co Starring Reshel Mae as Kenzie Dawson Towery as Donner Betsy Currie as Teacher #2 Jasper Keen as Barry Valoneecia Tolbert as Teacher #1