Guest Stars Taylor Richardson as Bridget Kelli O'Hara as Aurora Fane Debra Monk as Armstrong Ben Ahlers as Jack Trotter Celia Keenan-Bolger as Mrs. Bruce Kristine Nielsen as Mrs. Bauer Patrick Page as Richard Clay Douglas Sills as Monsieur Baudin Michael Cerveris as Watson Nathan Lane as Ward McAllister Audra McDonald as Dorothy Scott Donna Murphy as Caroline Schermerhorn Astor Erin Wilhelmi as Adelheid Claybourne Elder as John Adams Amy Forsyth as Caroline 'Carrie' Astor Ashlie Atkinson as Mamie Fish Zuzanna Szadkowski as Mabel Ainsley Rebecca Haden as Flora McNeil Brian Keane as Mr. Brand Henry Stram as Mr. Lewis Nancy Anderson as Sarah Taintor Gibbons Co Starring William Ryall as Mr. Hefty Melanie Moore as Sally Drexel Nick Ziobro as McNeil Footman Kylie Victoria Edwards as Angela Schermerhorn Joshua Burrage as Male Quadrille Dancer Evan Kinnane as Male Quadrille Dancer Raynor Rubel as Male Quadrille Dancer Davis Wayne as Male Quadrille Dancer Christopher Harrod as Prosecutor John Carrafa as Dancing Master Conan McCarty as Judge Katherine Laheen as Bloomingdales Assistant Paul Slade Smith as Union Club Waiter Jacob Keith Watson as John Dixon