Guest Stars Kate Eastman as Tamara Stefano Charlie Hudson III as Steven Turner Kristin Griffith as Cassandra Wall Eden Marryshow as John Smith Jacqueline Antaramian as Bobbi Co Starring Gameela Wright as Erika Lewis Martin Sola as Father Russo Allyson R. Hood as Grad Student Paris Benjamin as Older Melody Nick Pasqual as Peter Andy S. Allen as Eliot Tressa Glover as Sister Ann Ahlam Abbas as Julia Bennett Lena Josephine Marano as Young Melody