Special Guest Stars Alana De La Garza as Special Agent in Charge Isobel Castile Guest Stars Tonye Patano as Susan "Mama B" Barnes Enid Graham as Laura Mercer Zach Grenier as Vasily Matrushok Lilli Stein as Natalie Nick Thurston as Will Conway Keeley Miller as Marianne Conway Co Starring Logan Wyllie as Baby Theo Ellie Fishman as Julie Colin Hylander as Vermont Police Officer Tatyana Yassukovich as Olga Michael Garrett Boxleitner as Michael Aria Ashlyn Goodson as Rachel Conway Gabriel Wright as Rodney Griffiths Mario Peguero as Victor Ruiz Zalman Akbashev as Andrei Wesley Volcy as Raymont Griffiths Wendy Gutierrez as Lupe Ruiz Cullen R. Titmas as Montpelier PD Detective
