Guest Stars Philip Sternberg as Nathan Foster Ryan Belleville as Lionel Carlson Sadie Munroe as Alice Carlson Sarah McVie as Val Szalinsky Nikki Duval as Rosie Nolan Gahan as Charlie Foster Mason Gahan as Charlie Foster Dylan Taylor as Paul Kyle Harrison Breitkopf as Nathan Jr. Alex Mallari Jr as Malcolm Cody Patrick Aiza Ntibarikure as Maya Bronte Kristin Booth as Cheryl Brewer Ray Galletti as Jonathan Ali Momen as Walker Inga Cadranel as Tome Luke Kimball as Bennett Brewer Elise Bauman as Rebecca Anderson Martha Girvin as Heather Brooke Palsson as Nina Harris Franco Lo Presti as Kim Vanessa Jackson as Testimonial Woman #2 Dylan Trowbridge as Dale Allison-Dawn Doiron as Testimonial Woman #1 Marium Carvell as Judge Deb A John Balabik as Bailiff Keda Edwards Pierre as Dr. Vance