Guest Stars Carson Holmes as Three Langmore Nelson Bonilla as Nelson Katrina Lenk as Clare Shaw Madison Thompson as Erin Pierce Richard Thomas as Nathan Davis Bruno Bichir as Father Benitez Jane McNeill as Annalise CC Castillo as Sheriff Leigh Guerrero Ali Stroker as Charles-Ann "Chuck" Co Starring Tess Malis Kincaid as SAC Hannah Clay Lindsay Ayliffe as Harry Dave MacDonald as Connor McVeigh Michelle Rivera as Julia Reyes Dani Deetté as Sheriff Kim Reddick Douglas Dickerman as Gene Pierce Logan Siu as Wyatt's Friend Wes Jetton as Junior Agent John Crosby as Preacher Nicholas Calabrese as Corrections Officer