Guest Stars Christopher Heyerdahl as Ammon Lafferty Andrew Burnap as Joseph Smith Tyner Rushing as Emma Smith Co Starring Taylor St. Pierre as Jacob Lafferty Megan Leitch as Doreen Lafferty Britt Irvin as Sarah Lafferty Rohan Mead as Morris Sienna King as Annie Pyre Alba Evora Weiler as Caroline Pyre Michele Wienecke as Lynn Lafferty Carina Battrick as Sam's Jenny Lafferty Nicholas Carella as Brady Jerod Blake as Desk Cop Barclay Hope as Chief Rick Belnap Gillian Barber as Sister Dorren Micah Steinke as Desk Cop #2 Graham Abbey as Bishop Young Tom Rooney as Bishop Low Alayna Edwards as Sam's Girl 2 Declan O'Reilly as Ohio Town Official Christopher Duthie as Reporter #3 Jerry Callaghan as Male Temple Worker Daniel Libman as Roy Ballard Chris Duchaine as Reporter #2 Wil Little Thompson as Rodney Nichols Paul Wood as Thin Man Stephane Legault as Trooper Langford Kirk Heuser as Tribune Reporter Tim Campbell as Leconte Bascom Roel Suasin as Reporter #1 Dante Rice as ATV Boy #2 Bryan J. McHale as Jim Lewis Daria Banu as Ann Randuk Aidan Hamilton as ATV Boy #1 Neil Enock as Ponytailed Man Ray Pearson as Young Girl's Uncle (Kirtland) Chiara Petersen as Young Girl (Kirtland)