Guest Stars Jaime Ray Newman as Lucille Abshire Michael Park as Philip Abshire Brian Altemus as Young Henry DeTamble Caitlin Shorey as Tween Clare Abshire Josh Stamberg as Richard DeTamble Kate Siegel as Annette DeTamble Peter Graham as Mark Abshire Taylor Richardson as Alicia Abshire Will Brill as Ben Co Starring Gui Agustini as Henry's Acting Double Joanna Parson as Church Official James Hindman as Priest 2008 Raymond Russell Hamlin as Cameraman Finnerty Steeves as Realtor J.Y. Chun as Store Employee John E. Denaro as Priest 1979