Guest Stars Jake Cannavale as Caesar Lou Ferrigno as Lenny Montana Josh Zuckerman as Peter Bart Meredith Garretson as Ali MacGraw Anthony Ippolito as Al Pacino Joseph Russo as "Crazy" Joe Gallo T.J. Thyne as Gordy Willis Eric Balfour as Dean Tavoularis James Madio as Carmine Annie Funke as Sheila Paul McCrane as Jack Ballard Justin Chambers as Marlon Brando Stephanie Koenig as Andrea Eastman Danny Nucci as Congressman Mario Biaggi Zack Schor as Fred Gallo Geoffrey Arend as Aram Avakian Branden Williams as Gianni Russo Co Starring Tracy Silver as Bluhdorn's Secretary Christopher Wallinger as Agent Zabel Mark Berry as Agent Richman Nick Pupo as John Cazale Turhan Troy Caylak as Richard "Dickie" Dunston Damian Conrad-Davis as James Caan Derek Magyar as Robert Duvall Maya Butler as Diane Keaton Cynthia Aileen as Talia Shire Emil Beheshti as Surveyor #1 Christopher Wolfe as Italian League Reporter #1 O'Shay Neal as Jamar Jackson Christian Roberts as Italian League Reporter #3 Brian S. Carpenter as Italian League Reporter #2 Dawn Joyal as Anna Johnstone Jason Boegh as Polo Lounge Maître d Lisa Dobbyn as Morgana King Taissa Zveiter as Carmine's Wife Charlie Heydt as Jim Aubrey