Guest Stars Walt Roberts as Buddy Mohammad Hindi as Mustafa Ahmad Rajeh as Young Mo Lee Eddy as Lizzie Horowitz Cherien Dabis as Nadia Bill Dawes as Bob Robinson Bianca Sia as Sajdah Co Starring Carlos Lerman as Manny Mariam Albishah as Nadia (Age 18) Samuel Davis as Damon Joe Brooks Jr. as Curtis Carol Hickey as Eilleen Koehler Idris Abdellaoui as Osama Carlos Sachez as Tough Kid #1 Xedrick Jabier as Tough Kid #2 Jai Renfro as Ira / Bayside Player Carrie Bourn as Ira's Mom