Special Guest Stars Erik Palladino as Lt. Michael Daghlian Guest Stars Chris Marquette as Adam Rove Becky Wahlstrom as Grace Polk Elaine Hendrix as Ms. Lischak Sydney Tamiia Poitier as Rebecca Askew John Getz as D.A. Gabe Fellowes Kara Zediker as Sara Bonner Candice Azzara as Housewife God Nate Dushku as Clay Fisher Jeremy Garrett as Todd Bainbridge David Doty as Businessman God Co Starring Barbara Evans as Jeanne Andrew Ableson as Andy Rees Daniel Edward Mora as Deliveryman God Jan Devereaux as Lisa Van Horn Andy Forrest as Shopper Scott Damian as Reporter