Guest Stars Aaron Himelstein as Friedman Mageina Tovah as Glynis Figliola Mark Totty as Det. Carlisle Sprague Grayden as Judith Montgomery Kris Lemche as Cute Boy God Jeffrey Licon as Goth Kid God Kathryn Joosten as Old Lady God Riley Smith as Andy Baker Jack Plotnick as The Other Sammy Ransford Doherty as DeShawn Wallace Dayo Ade as Ruben Holloway Michael Hyatt as Mary Wallace Co Starring Jack Merrill as Uniformed Officer Timothy McNeil as Dr. Dan Radovitch Julian Reyes as Detective