Special Guest Stars Kevin Rahm as Dana Tuchman Guest Stars Aaron Himelstein as Friedman Mageina Tovah as Glynis Figliola Mark Totty as Det. Carlisle Annie Potts as Lt. Lucy Preston Constance Zimmer as Sister Lilly Watters Jeffrey Licon as Goth Kid God Kimberly McCullough as Beth Rinehart Jack Plotnick as The Other Sammy John Marshall Jones as Chessmaster God Mark Matkevich as Roger Jane Daly as Janet Tuchman René Ashton as Female Motivational Speaker God Yorgo Constantine as Vladamir Karpovic Co Starring Jack Merrill as Uniformed Officer Adrian Bloom as Waiter