Guest Stars Dale Dickey as Sergeant Beverly Kendall Johnson as Gary Hall Alex Désert as Edgar Chapman Saidah Arrika Ekulona as Toni Chapman Aaron Jennings as Guy Morgan Patrick J. Adams as Charlie Shaw Nick Offerman as Casey "Dove" Porter Treisa Gary as Georgia Diane Sellers as Lynn Marinda Anderson as Leah Mitch Eakins as Vernon Co Starring Rae Gray as Terri Cobell Lil Frex as Ana Blair Jon Osbeck as Bob the Announcer Don Fanelli as Alan Baker Jr. Madeline Seidman as Caren Tressa Glover as Karen Jeff Hochendoner as Umpire Brandon Dahlquist as Jim Fowkes David Case as Roger Debbie Norrell as Playful Aunty Aqeel Ash-Shakoor as Pastor Turner John Shepard as Lou Parker Alan Bomar Jones as Pastor Presley Adrianne Kelly as Miss Gladys Carol Massenburg as Church Lady