Guest Stars Evan Ellison as Sebastian Zelle Jason Sakaki as Isaac Kimura Tahmoh Penikett as Malachi Dodds Ty Wood as Teddy Harrington Marci T. House as Adele Thornton Bradley Stryker as Sheriff Wilkins Eva Bourne as Gina Brooks Djouliet Amara as Tatiana Nelson Laura Soltis as Cheryl Thurmond Keenan Tracey as Noah Co Starring Samantha Ferris as Rhoda Morrison Heather Feeney as Purple-Robed Nun Arianna Bent as Angelica Lia Frankland as Melissa Green Gabriel Carter as Man in Jeans Jilena Cori as Nurse Jane Ash Lee as Larry Gillium Conor Stinson O'Gorman as Scarecrow Frances Leigh as Bartender Eva Brooke Baker as Young Mae Jared Arthur as Caleb Dodd Safina Rasulova as Cheerleader Trey Jordan as Teen Patient Liam Saretsky as Billy