Special Guest Stars Cobie Smulders as Simone Bates Kyle Bornheimer as Patrick Twiley Co Starring C.J. Valleroy as Evan Christian Humphries as Andrew Daniel Beirne as Mr. Gardner Marcus Della Rosa as Tyler Christopher Heatherington as English Teacher Shawn Seward as Kevin Autumn T. Dang as Female Student Alyssa Hassett as Pretty Girl Sharon Umeh as Girl