Special Guest Stars Jan Broberg as Jan's Therapist Guest Stars Joe Chrest as Bishop Matthew Paulse Meg Steedle as Sherry Patrick Fischler as Garth Pincock Will Buie, Jr. as Eric Paul Schneider as Marty Co Starring Norah Murphy as Older Susan Broberg Maggie Sonnier as Older Karen Broberg Richard Hempton as Howard Armstrong Ava Grace Roberts as Nicole Paulsen Ava Leigh as Carly Bay Allebach as Older Caroline Hansen Sara Antonio as Nurse Judy Elizabeth Becka as Judge Emma Faith as Melanie Kelvin Hodge as Lockhart Ethan Daniels as Sean Ben Bladon as Mee