Guest Stars Ava Yaghmaie as Joanie Heydari Ralph Adriel Johnson as Phillip Josh Radnor as Adam Epstein Brian Miskell as Clay Clifton Frances Li as Vanessa Lipschitz-Finkelstein John Patrick Hayden as David Cooper Joe Tuttle as Glenn Christian Slater as Archer Sylvan Cynthia Sosa as Sandra Co Starring Julie Tolivar as Karen Cooper Oscar Bennett as Miles Epstein Lucinda Lee Dawson Gray as Sasha Epstein Tara Westwood as Amy Nina Kassa as Annie Erin Breen as Allison Yaron Lotan as Brian Julianna Zinkel as Suburban Mom Nathaniel Levin as Bro #1 Matthew J. Harris as Bro #3 Michael Alexander Henry as Mike Michelle Beck as Michelle Christopher Domig as John Faith Score as Babysitter Jonathan Lipnick as Rabbi Turko