Guest Stars Roxana Brusso as Andrea Reyes D.B. Woodside as Reverend Trevor Parks Lyndsy Fonseca as Iris Blake Amanda Schull as Special Agent Rose Kasey McKaley Miller as Brianna Sean H. Scully as Caleb Co Starring Scott Peat as Turner Dan Sanders-Joyce as Red Pickney Richard Meehan as Mikey Bella Blanding as Melody Parks LaSaundra Gibson as Meteorologist Roland Ruiz as Seth Patricia Mizen as Anchor Sharon Omi as Jane Kevin Benton as Pastor Roper Caitlin Duffy as Distraught Woman Dustin Pewitt as Eric