Guest Stars Tim Daly as Ulysses S. Thatcher Tyriq Withers as Connor Tibbs Andrea Laing as Erika Robert Christopher Riley as Chance Worley Carson Fagerbakke as Allison Morris Jared Simon as Paxton Rick Fox as Himself Philip Fornah as Apollo Maze Co Starring Alec Michael Adams as Delivery Guy Mystie Smith as Candice Ross Cynthia Barker as Porscha