Special Guest Stars Michelle Gomez as Madame Rouge Guest Stars Mark Sheppard as Willoughby Kipling Sendhil Ramamurthy as Mr. 104 Elijah R. Reed as Deric Co Starring Hannah Alline as Pretty Polly Shay Mack as Driller Bill Ethan McDowell as Agent Charles Forsythe Tim Peek as Knight Templar #1 Braelyn Rankins as Young Vic Lana Jean Turner as Young Rita Zuri James as Calvin Moses Jones as Marcus Macoy Stewart as Charlie Sparrow Nicole as Winona Tyler Crumley as Young Willoughby Ava Grace Roberts as Young Rouge Robby Sherwood as Jeremy