Guest Stars Fedna Jacquet as Charlotte Gaines Tonye Patano as Susan "Mama B" Barnes Zoë Sophia Garcia as Kim Fogelman Shaun Anthony as Joshua Fogelman Eva Kaminsky as Penny Fleming Jimmy Nicholas as Wolfgang Blair Wendy Lyon as Tanya Waters Stephen Singer as Damon Marshall Nancy Rodriguez as Liliana Alzugaray Co Starring Raigan Olivia Newton as Anais Barnes-Gaines Maceo Oliver as Matt Sundeen Michael Barra as Carl Josh Davis as Detective Phil Grady Bjorn Joseph as PD Officer Stone Gilbert L. Bailey II as Pastor Douglas LA Head as Betty Roslyn Seale as Leona Sundeen Jamie Petrone as AUSA Megan Vickers Nadia Ramdass as PD Officer Cox Jonathan Auguste as Bram Brian O'Brien as Dominic Howard Kamran Abbassian as Security Guard Pia Smith as Liz Ted Koch as Colonel Ned Cowell