Guest Stars Jasmin Walker as Natalie Brian d'Arcy James as Bruce Joshua Echebiri as Reverend Eric Turner Robin Tunney as Jane Clara Wong as Daphne Ashley De La Rosa as Sienna Amr El-Bayoumi as Faakhir Andrew Burnap as Father Macelvoy Steve Kornacki as Himself Co Starring Vanessa Huszar as Geena Chris Giarmo as Ticket Taker Zachary Greenstein as 4-Year-Old Eddie Kelsey Rainwater as Renee Lucie Vuong as Yang Lee Bonnie Rose as House Leader Dionelis Barragan as Sylvie Morgan O'Kane as Banjo Player Ferd Moyse as Fiddle Player Uttera Singh as Madison Isaac Bae as Young Steve Alexander Leonard as Young Brent Huirong Lucy Lu as Grandma