Guest Stars Nolan North as Jerry Lansing Casper Van Dien as John Boutell Felicia Day as Karen Sean Astin as Himself Natasha Price as Scooter Fan Sasha Feiler as Sagan Aurora Kilauea Oliphant Yann Sicamois as Mithrandir Elessar Peregrin Smith III Madison Brunoehler as Hopeful Fan Jovita Charissa Barton as Pregnant Looking Fan Marisa Grieco as Cosplay Belaran