Guest Stars Aisha Tyler as Dr. Tara Elisabeth Lewis Taylor Spreitler as Riley Desario Joel Gretsch as Sheriff Paul Desario Sydney Mikayla as Maggie Crewswick Carole Gutierrez as M.E. Jacoby Jon Knapp as Kyle Lincoln Aubrey Cleland as Victoria Taylor Noah Crawford as Matt Franks Kurt Scholler as Randy Nelson Rubén Garfias as Reverend Jorge Santos Lawrence Mandley as Steve Halvert Mark Chaet as Ira Stein Jakob Salvati as Danny Desario Nolan Bateman as Adam Jenkins Will Babbitt as Trevor Farson Derrick Redford as Nick Baleman