Guest Stars Kym Whitley as Florynce Kennedy Nick Kroll as Schmuck Mudman Wanda Sykes as Shirley Chisholm Colton Dunn as Conrad Chisholm Marla Gibbs as Ruby Seale Brock O'Hurn as Swole Body Malcolm Barrett as Idi Amin Sarah Silverman as Lieutenant Silverman David Duchovny as Howard Cosell Impersonator Emily Ratajkowski as Movie Mary Magdalene Nick Kroll as Man on Toilet Casey Wilson as Movie Mother Mary Jillian Bell as Nicaea Moderator Wanda Sykes as Dr. Kaufmanberg Ike Barinholtz as Borowitz Ike Barinholtz as Teddy Roosevelt Brock O'Hurn as Movie Jesus Blake Griffin as Muhammad Ali Co Starring Edgar Blackmon as Audience Member Joe Lo Truglio as Red Bishop Paul Rust as Convention Worker Ken Marino as Bishop Lennon Parham as Greta Adam Pally as Movie Judas Reggie Watts as Hans Hayes MacArthur as Movie Mark Josh Fadem as Moneylender Matt Corboy as Monopolist Seth Morris as Aisle Guy David Wain as Bishop Neville Archamblault as Neville Gracen Newton as Little Boy Gil Ozeri as Joot Matt Rogers voices Movie Announcer Katherine LaVeaux as Hat Check Girl Rosalind Russell as Rosa Parks