Guest Stars Owen Painter as Young Lucas Merritt Wever as Frankie Pierce Michaela Watkins as Amy Adler Marlow Barkley as Little Clare John Bishop as Ned Roger Aaron Brown as James Luenell as Aunt Felicia Conni Marie Brazelton as Sondra Co Starring Mark Anthony Williams as Narrator Margot Catherine Terry as Little Rae Chloe Castiglioni as Terrified Mother Giosué Bottini as Little Lucas