Guest Stars Geoff Stults as Jake Davis Michael Hyatt as Maris Anderson Mary Birdsong as Elenor McGovern Victor Garber as Professor Tobias Cookman Matt Craven as Andrew Hall Taylor Dearden as Cheryl Cece Kelly as Young Hannah Co Starring Elizabeth O'Donnell as Ed Jake Matthews as Larry London Garcia as Rochelle Mateo Gallardo as Marco Cassie Osuji as Young Jules Raven Troup as Librarian