Guest Stars Lisseth Chavez as Officer Celina Juarez Arjay Smith as James Murray Felicia Day as Dr. Morgan Preeti Desai as Charlie Bristow Kyle Schmid as Noah Foster Augie Duke as Raelynn Jameson Kyle Davis as Vince Jameson Lee Simpson as Matthew Northrop Tom Plumley as Kip Sherborn Dani Bryan as Girlfriend Co Starring Kondwani Phiri as Robert Betts Elaine Whae as Flora Jeff Karr as Phil Dee Bryant as Bus Driver