Guest Stars Matilda Szydagis as Zelda Joel Johnstone as Archie Cleary Jason Ralph as Mike Carr Will Brill as Noah Weissman Eddie Kaye Thomas as Adam Austin Basis as Alvin Michael Cyril Creighton as Mel Chris Eigeman as Gabe Lucas Kavner as Cecil Josh Grisetti as Ralph Alexander Gemignani as Janusz Peter Friedman as George Veanne Cox as Corinne Annie Golden as Marge Milo Ventimiglia as Sylvio Alexandra Socha as Adult Esther Currie Graham as Mike Wallace Lucy Taylor as Penelope Co Starring Colin Keane as Ethan Sedona Carvajal as Esther Ireland Carvajal as Esther Malika Samuel as Dorie Chloë Kerwin as Trudy David Chase as Band Leader Jim Hershman as Gordon Ford Band Member Mark Lopeman as Gordon Ford Band Member John Allred as Gordon Ford Band Member Daniel Levine as Gordon Ford Band Member Clint De Ganon as Gordon Ford Band Member Don Downs as Gordon Ford Band Member Marc Phaneuf as Gordon Ford Band Member John Noble Barrack as Stage Manager Chris Lewis as Gordon Ford Band Member David Mann as Gordon Ford Band Member Kevin Pariseau as Terrence Tony Kadleck as Gordon Ford Band Member Steve Greenstein as Toots Shor Alexander Blaise as Lance Danny Doherty as Cop Steve Belanger as Policeman Darlene Violette as Offended Woman Eric Wheeler as Gordon Ford Band Member