Guest Stars Sarah Gilman as Penny Gill Derek Webster as Dr. Milton Hudson Daniel Di Tomasso as Trey Cahill Lolita Davidovich as Jeanette Folsom Shane Callahan as Kahn Schefter Erica Piccininni as Young Jeanette Caden Dragomer as Young Josh Kevin Fonteyne as Jared Ott Co Starring Kevin Brief as Granddad Tyler David Carrera as Father Sophie Cook as Dancer Rhys Jackson Becker as Young Trey
