Special Guest Stars Mark-Paul Gosselaar as Paul Campano Guest Stars LisaGay Hamilton as Evelyn Mitchell Greg Germann as James Ulster Imani Hakim as Young Evelyn Sydney Park as Young Amanda Tom Schanley as Butch Bonnie Tamara Clatterbuck as Kitty Treadwell Co Starring Raiany Silva as Lucy Morales Kent Fields as Rick Landry Josh Hooks as Young Butch Bonnie Jef Holbrook as Random Person Renae Geerlings as Dr. Bridges Popin Pete as Bruce Tywaun Tornes as Uniform
