Guest Stars Annabelle Dexter-Jones as Serena Miles Mussenden as Detective Quincy Burrell Brandon Keener as Paul Aisha Alfa as Carolyn Aaron Staton as Simon Timm Sharp as Richard Hugh Scott as Night Prowler Alex Livinalli as Seattle Stalker Bob Rumnock as I-20 Sniper Ervin Ross as Subway Strangler Aliya Kamalova as Spring Break Slayer