Guest Stars Jordan Rice as Jackie Monique Grant as Keisha Marksby Vinessa Shaw as Diane Harrison-Fitzpatrick Christopher B. Duncan as Camden Ryder Sr. Al Mitchell as Coach Joe Warrick Demetrius Grosse as Grant Carson Jennifer Patino as Krista Cooke Scott Daniel Johnson as Paul Marquette Co Starring RJ Thomas as Johnny Fitzpatrick Wayne Hughes as Seymour Greyson Caroline Gregory as Amber Gibbons Bakari Blocton as Young Jace Arlise Raeli-Marie Minter as Kathryn Edwards Kennedy Dream as Young Crystal Kaci Barker as Drea Catherine Owens as Rae Tedd Taskey as Mike Reese Kameron Wells as Roderick Oliver Blank as Cedar Cove Student Laura Avnaim as Mary Davin Cosby Jr. as Olympiad Prep Player Caroline Ainsley Patterson as Jessica Taylor Grae as Counselor Kate Paige Marie Smeltzer as Amy Sarah Grace Drake as Casey Kevin Murray as Mr. Toole Chaz Riddle as Olympiad Coach