Guest Stars Sam Ashby as Jackson Lewis Hunter Burke as Trotter Vidhyarkorn Tracey Bonner as Pastor June Wilkes Brittany L. Smith as Peggy Martin Caroline Lagerfelt as Paula Vreeland Frank Oakley III as Harlan Bixby Michael Shenefelt as Ryan Wingate Allison Gabriel as Mary Vaughn Lewis Elena House as Lily Greta Glenn as Henrietta Jermaine Love as David