Guest Stars Kat Foster as Nicole Brandt Susan Park as Dr. Monica Crumb Cristin Milioti as Sketch Artist Betty Gilpin as Abigail Allen / Margo Stanford Geneva Carr as Cheryl Thayler Matt Servitto as Dr. Andre Zamacona Adam Driver as Will Slansky Ashlie Atkinson as Tanya Blanston Ray Wills as Robert Thayler Austin Lysy as Chris Treadwell Luther Creek as Arliss Storch Kim Sykes as Denise Kraft André Blake as Donald Kraft Stuart Burney as Lawyer Carmen Lopez as Marianne Morales Del Pentecost as Norm Blanston David Cale as Victor Baker Beth Leavel as Ellen Baker Poppy Cerqueira as Porn Starlet #1 Claudia L. Brown as Porn Starlet #2