Guest Stars Gavin Munn as Abraham Gemstone Kelton DuMont as Pontius Gemstone Walton Goggins as Baby Billy Freeman Jody Hill as Levi Valyn Hall as Tiffany Freeman Kristen Johnston as May-May Montgomery Stephen Dorff as Vance Simkins Steve Zahn as Peter Montgomery Lukas Haas as Chuck Montgomery Robert Oberst as Karl Montgomery Stephen Schneider as Stephen Maggie Winters as Taryn Co Starring Eric Goins as Pastor Brad Bruce Taylor as Cape & Pistol Society Leader Marlo Scheitler as Martin's Wife Rakesh Gosain as Cape & Pistol Member Nicholas Vardakas as Teen Finn Carmichael as Maxwell Wimberly Gabriella Garcia as Makayla Liz McGeever as Mrs. Wimberly George Paez as Biker Clarence Roxy Rivera as Mrs. Carlisle Nick Arapoglou as Teens United Dad Bobby Burns as Henry Dajalynn Sanchez as Carlisle Teen
