Special Guest Stars Kellita Smith as Judge Vonetta Sears Guest Stars Yolanda T. Ross as Antionette 'Tony' McCullough Ellana Barksdale as Deidra "Big D" Walls Pamela Threats as Agent Marsha Diggs Lizzie Peet as Sheriff Bobbi Olsen Jack Impellizzeri as Peter Corbin Wendi Bazar as Elena Marzili Erik Passoja as Governor Barclay Mike Strong as Young Judge Reinhart Jared Becker as Young James Barclay Co Starring Nyree Neil as Tracy Michelle Nelson Tina Tena Ansah as D.A. Landry Aleis Work as Meagan Barclay Toy Connor as Young Sears Caleb Thermidor as Young Sloan Brett Muckler as Male FBI Agent #2 Ali Faizaan as Male FBI Agent #1 Miriam Felps as Sarah Barclay Raquel McPherson as Gorgeous Woman Isaac Middleton as Reverend Gregory Mario Antonio as Eddie Isaiah West as Young Othello Ty Brown as Teen Daniel Zariah Dancy as Young Daniel Conrad Wrobel as Young Peter Corbin Ernest Dancy as Young Benjamin Sr. Carlos Demond Davis as Young Reverend McCullough Kiera Rose as Young Lacey Jai Dion voices Young Her Akia Takara as Young Floyd Fana Minea Tesfagiogis as Young Big D Raquelle Wallace as Young Tony Princess Fortier as Female FBI Agent