Guest Stars Gavin Munn as Abraham Gemstone Kelton DuMont as Pontius Gemstone Walton Goggins as Baby Billy Freeman Jody Hill as Levi Valyn Hall as Tiffany Freeman Troy Hogan as Matthew J. LaRose as Gregory James DuMont as Chad Mary Hollis Inboden as Mandy Kristen Johnston as May-May Montgomery Stephen Dorff as Vance Simkins Steve Zahn as Peter Montgomery Lukas Haas as Chuck Montgomery Robert Oberst as Karl Montgomery Gogo Lomo-David as Craig Simkins Shea Whigham as Dusty Daniels Iliza Shlesinger as Shay Simkins Co Starring Jennifer Hazelip as Pam Crystal Coney as Angie Eric Goins as Pastor Brad Bruce Taylor as Cape & Pistol Society Leader Rakesh Gosain as Cape & Pistol Member Piya Karthikeyan as Simkins Child Ashlea Kosikowski as News Anchor Kevin Murray as Gene Hackman Lookalike Chloe Bremer as Simkins Child
