Guest Stars Paola Núñez as Doctor Alessandra Ruiz Igby Rigney as Toby Annabeth Gish as Eliza Robert Longstreet as William Longfellow Co Starring Nicholas Lea as Judge John Neal Daniel Jun as Julius Aya Furukawa as Tina Jason Tremblay as Dupin's Legal Aid Mark Redfield as Preacher Paul Jarrett as Doctor Donaldson Graham Verchere as Younger Roderick Lulu Wilson as Younger Madeline Sarah Jane Redmond as Longfellow's Wife Britney Katelyn Miller as Young Woman at Leo's Kate Whiddington as Tiny Madeline Lincoln Russo as Tiny Roderick Gus Tayari as Butler
